Sign up to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter for all the latest new and updates.

Become a member

Membership of Type allows unlimited access to our online library. Join to support new research and writing on the design of the built environment.

You can read more about membership here.

Become a member

Already a member? Login to your account to avail of unlimited downloads.

Learning from the design of migrant landscapes in Irish urban settlements

Rawan Osman
21/11/2022

Present Tense

The creation of cultural clusters is a common feature of migrant histories globally, yet the design of migrant settlements in Ireland is a topic often unacknowledged or under discussed. Taking the Ballyhaunis mosque complex as an example, this article seeks to better understand the role architecture can play in expressing a unique migrant identity.

Ballyhaunis mosque. Photography by Rawan Kamal

Comprising a main commercial street, St Patrick’s Roman Catholic Church, and residential quarters, on the surface Ballyhaunis's appearance is similar to comparable Irish towns. However, beyond the main street, one is confronted by complex cultural and architectural expressions.

As part of an effort to create a replica of ‘home’ in recipient cities, migrants tend to create cultural heritage clusters. Generally, these consist of residential quarters, factories, and commercial shopfronts, with their form influenced by factors including class, dietary laws, transport availability, and proximity to work and religious spaces [1]. This concept is not new, with migrants being actively engaged in forming and transforming the built environment across time. Hence, we must consider how we understand and make visible migrant histories and cultures within modern urban landscapes.


During the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, a significant number of migrants settled across Co. Mayo, resulting in high levels of ethnic diversity [2]. This was affirmed in the 2016 Census, with Ballyhaunis recording the highest population of non-Irish nationals in an Irish town, making up 39.5% of its population [3]. Historically, the Midland Great Western Railway, arriving in Co. Mayo in 1860, enabled this, connecting towns such as Ballyhaunis with a direct route to Dublin and surrounding urban settlements. As a result, these town’s became the county’s major commercial hubs [4]. Comprising a main commercial street, St Patrick’s Roman Catholic Church, and residential quarters, on the surface Ballyhaunis's appearance is similar to comparable Irish towns. However, beyond the main street, one is confronted by complex cultural and architectural expressions. As a result, the town reveals urban, spatial, and cultural diversity, stimulating research into migration and architecture.

‍

Map of Ballyhaunis, with retail/halal shops (green), industrial facility/halal meat factory (blue), and residential area/migrant housing (red) highlighted. Drawing by Rawan Kamal


Described by the local community as “The houses behind the wall”, the area behind Clare Road has housed Pakistani migrants since the 1970s [5]. This cultural and religious group have established the most evident spatial impact, forming a distinctive migrant cluster with a strong Islamic character. Architecturally, the development of the migrant cluster engages both sides of Clare Road. On one side, a high and continuous brick wall with vertical corrugated sheets spans more than 318m, delineating the territory of Dawns Meat Factory, the workplace for many Pakistani migrants. This is mirrored on the other by a heavy hedge and vast parking space, which ultimately obscures the small Pakistani neighbourhood behind. In this, migrant workers and their families reside and are able to perform the five daily Islamic prayers, privately, within the enclosed space. Considering the requirement for privacy, one can suggest the location of the factory and the need for proximity as playing a pivotal role in the selection of the site for the residential quarter [6]. The housing units, which comprise four detached units, five semi-detached units, four terraced houses, and eight bungalows, can be accessed via Mosque Street off Clare Road [7]. As is typical across many workers’ dwellings, primitive means of construction were harnessed, ultimately leading to properties with low architectural value. Gas cylinders and enormous ground water tanks attached to the rear, along with deteriorating paint, are evidence of this. In contrast, a large opulent multi-storey mansion takes a central position within the quarter. The architecture denotes a difference grounded in affluence. This structure and the migrant houses were constructed by the Pakistani-British proprietor of the adjacent factory.

‍

House built by the meat factory owner. Photography by Rawan Kamal


Migrant housing. Photography by Rawan Kamal

‍

At the community level sits the Ballyhaunis mosque, built in 1987. The uniform plan, bulbous dome, and architectural elements recall the Indo-Islamic tradition of Mughal architecture, specifically the architectural style of seventeenth century mosques in Asia [8]. Dark-green and white walls denote the mosque’s outer edge, with the colours a subtle homage to Pakistan’s national flag. Located at a focal point, along the main axis of the estate, the Ballyhaunis mosque draws attention away from the housing’s diametric differences. As such, the mosque captures the identity of the migrant community, and perhaps represents the strongest and most striking architectural element in the traditional Catholic landscape of Ballyhaunis.


This case study highlights a unique and significant example of a landscape in rural Ireland that was crafted by immigrants. Beyond the mosque’s architecture, the surrounding block walls, densely planted entrance, and isolated community services reflect a distinct urban culture and present a form which is culturally consistent with Islamic values. While only one example, the Ballyhaunis mosque complex should be noted as a significant migrant landscape, one that exhibits the role architecture can play in expressing a unique migrant identity.

Located at a focal point, along the main axis of the estate, the Ballyhaunis mosque draws attention away from the housing’s diametric differences. As such, the mosque captures the identity of the migrant community, and perhaps represents the strongest and most striking architectural element in the traditional Catholic landscape of Ballyhaunis.

Present Tense is an article series aimed at uncovering perspectives and opinions from experts in their respective fields on the key issues/opportunities facing Ireland's built environment. For all enquiries and potential contributors, please contact info@type.ie.

Present Tense is supported by the Arts Council through the Architecture Project Award Round 2 2022.

References

1. P. Knox and S. Pinch, Urban Social Geography: An Introduction, 6th ed. Essex, Pearson Education Limited, 2010, pp. 172-173.

2. Central Statistics Office Data (CSO) 2016. Accessed 29 September 2022, https://www.cso.ie/en/census/.

3. Central Statistics Office Data (CSO) 2016. Accessed 29 September 2022, https://www.cso.ie/en/census/.

4. J.F. Quinn, Historyo f Mayo.Ballina, Co. Mayo, Brendan Quinn, 1993, p. 255.

5. Taken from an informal interview with the owner of Mulberry Lodge Guest House, Ballyhaunis, 2018.

6. According to the Ballyhaunis Development Plan of 1984, the Dawn Meats Factory was built on an industrial and premature zone.

7. Mayo County Council, Planning Permission Document Number (07189). Accessed 24 June 2021, https://www.eplanning.ie/MayoCC/AppFileRefDetails/07189/0.

8. E.Koch, Mughal Architecture, Oxford University Press, 2002.

Contributors

Rawan Osman

Rawan Osman is a doctoral candidate at University College Dublin. She holds a Bachelor of Architecture from the University of Khartoum and a Master of Urban and Building Conservation from University College Dublin. She practised as an architect and designer in Sudan. During her time at Paul Arnold Architects, she worked on various conservation and research projects in Ireland. Her research interests include migrants’ histories and their influence on both historic and contemporary spatial environments, conservation theory, historic urban landscapes, and intangible cultural heritage. In addition, exploring strategies and means for the inclusion of immaterial and tangible migrant cultures within the legislative framework of host cities.

Related articles

To Compartmentalise or Not, The Irish Pub Snug

Luke McSherry
Present Tense
Luke McSherry
Ciarán Brady

In a world over-saturated with "best pint" influencer interviews, it is high time we talk about the architecture of the snug. Passing through rural Irish towns this past summer, the visual decay of former licensed premises was a stark reminder of an evolving social landscape.

‍

This article sets out to categorise the distinct architectural periods of the Irish pub snug, and examine the cultural compartmentalisation of space in one of Ireland’s most indispensable venues: the public house.

‍

In 1990, the late architectural critic Frank McDonald wrote a piece in The Irish Times about "pub pastiche," noting: “Pubs are our Piazzas”, “people go to talk to their friends and to have a bit of craic” [1]. Craic being closely related to enclosed space as discussed by anthropologist Adam Kaul, when people experience a state of group ‘flow’ [2].

‍

Decades earlier, in 1950, The Architectural Review issued a challenge to architects in the form of a competition to design "The Public House of Tomorrow". The brief set out to conceive a public house truly of its time. The winning entries featured gleaming, cosmopolitan, open-plan bars with almost zero compartmentalisation [3]. Thirty years later, in 1980, Phil Lynott sat at the bar of The Long Hall in his music video for Old Town. Looking at that room, it was clear that very little had changed since the Victorian era. In fact, the only real anachronism watching it today is the heavy haze of cigarette smoke [4].

‍

Did the "pub of tomorrow" ever actually arrive, or did we ever really want it to? In Ireland, we still instinctively gravitate towards the Victorian pub as our one proudest architectural set pieces to be exported.

‍

Snugs originally emerged out of Victorian culture as tools for class segregation, moral purity, and capitalisation, allowing publicans to charge a premium for a private space. They were variously referred to as smoking rooms, tap rooms, parlours, or vaults. These spaces were reserved for specific clientele who wished to remain unseen by the rest of the bar: women, clergymen, local elites, and wanted republicans.

‍

This spatial segregation continued in Ireland far longer than many care to admit. In a cultural purge similar to the dissolution of the Anglo-Irish Big Houses, many original snugs and their hardwood interiors were ripped out during the mid to late 20th century in favour of ‘democratic’, open-plan bars. One can still find architectural remnants of this era; stepping into Mulligans on Poolbeg Street, you can see a lone, fragmented snug partition left hanging at the bar. In some enclaves like J. & K. Walsh in Waterford, the strict social segregation lingered so long that the barmaid notes women weren't truly integrated into the main bar counter space until 2002.

‍

J. & K. Walsh Lidar Scan. Image Credit: Luke McSherry

‍

A textbook example of an original Victorian snug can be found at Doheny & Nesbitt’s on Baggot Street. The telltale sign of its authenticity is its placement relative to the entrance. Genuine snugs are positioned immediately at the door so that clandestine clientele can slip inside without being noticed by the main room of men. This secrecy is reinforced by the opacity of the glass facing the street; the only sure way of knowing whether the snug is occupied is to try the door handle.

‍

Doheny & Nesbitt’s Worms Eye Lidar Scan. Image Credit: Luke McSherry

‍

Although the Victorians invented the form, the practice of building snugs continued well into the formation of the Irish Free State. The prevailing cultural forces of shame, privacy, and seclusion perfectly suited a newly established confessional state, which naturally extended into the construction of these confessional box-like pub spaces.

‍

In August 2026, I led a survey of the remaining snugs of Waterford City alongside Emily Naughton, Liam Egan, and a team of participants from around Europe as part of the European Architectural Students Assembly (EASA). During this fieldwork, it became apparent that Irish snugs can be divided into four distinct architectural typologies:

‍

1. The Victorian

The original blueprint. Built with heavy, high-quality hardwoods, ornate frosted or etched glass, beautiful mosaic flooring, and strategically placed immediately inside the tavern entrance to ensure total privacy from both the street and the public bar.

‍

2. The Irish

The "Irish" snug was a direct post-colonial continuation of Victorian spatial logic, adapted to the religious hegemony atmosphere of the Free State. A great example encountered in Waterford is at Phil Grimes on John’s Hill. It retains the exact same spatial qualities and secretive placement as its Victorian predecessor, but relies on more modest materials.

‍

Palace Bar Athlone drawing by Michael Scott Architect. Image Credit: Courtesy of the Irish Architectural Archive (ref. 79/10.25/3)

‍

Even Ireland’s early pioneer of modernism, Michael Scott, couldn't fully escape such spatial obligations. In the early 1940s, Scott drew up two unbuilt proposals for pub alterations: one on Abbey Street in Dublin and another for The Palace Bar in Athlone. While Scott was actively trying to open Ireland up to international architectural styles, his plans show that the instinct to compartmentalise remained. In Athlone, his drawings feature two snugs flanking the entrance as the walls sweep toward a curved bar; on Abbey Street, the footprint was strictly partitioned into a lounge, a snug, and a public bar [5].

‍

3. The Pastiche

The Pastiche snug is a product of contemporary, post-ecclesiastical Ireland, an architectural attempt to recapture the structural intimacy that was lost when original snugs were systematically demolished. These modern iterations are almost always placed toward the rear of the premises rather than the front.

‍

They vary wildly in execution. You find them in the hasty, bricolage construction of Tully’s Snug in Waterford, or the much more considered, rhythmic row of snugs formerly found in P.Mac’s on Stephen Street Lower in Dublin. Now removed in favour of a Scandinavian interior, some of these pubs represent a bizarre design loop: interiors that were aggressively gutted forty years ago, only to be reinstated less than two decades later under a new aesthetic guise.

‍

4. The Transplant

Nowadays people exist in their own hyper-curated algorithm of desired cultural reference points; some publicans choose to bypass imitation entirely and opt for the ‘Transplant’—or what a friend recently termed "colonial publicanism." This occurs when a venue salvages architectural elements of a defunct rural pub, or purchases an entire historic fit out, and drops it into a completely new urban context. A prominent example is Ashtons in Clonskeagh, which transplanted the interior of a former licensed premises from County Laois straight into the capital.

‍

Dawson Lounge Lidar Scan. Image Credit: Luke McSherry

‍

This summer, I visited one of the source environments for this trend, a pub graveyard in Kilbeggan, County Westmeath. The town, akin to many rural Irish towns, features half a dozen empty, shopfronts and licensed premises standing derelict on the main street. On the edge of town sits a massive salvage warehouse. Inside, there is an eerie, melancholy quality to the endless rows of pub paraphernalia, accompanied by a baked in, entirely familiar smell of damp timber, and antique piss.

‍

Entire hardwood counters are lined up for sale alongside fragmented pieces of local identity: decal opaque windows, disembodied snug doors, and faded photographs of historic GAA wins. Speaking with the owner, he noted that the vast majority of his customers aren't commercial publicans at all they are individual men looking for an authentic piece of history to bolt onto their suburban man caves.

‍

At a time when our physical environments are increasingly plateaued by the algorithms of AI-generated ‘slop’ interiors, mass produced Scandinavian living, and homogenous open spaces, the survival of the snug feels quietly radical. Whether original or pastiche, these micro architectures stand as a stubborn, physical reminder that human beings do not always want to be seen, democratic, or exposed. Sometimes, we just want to slide into the dark, closed plan spaces, close the latch, and look at the world through a pane of frosted glass.

16/11/2026
Present Tense

In this article, Luke McSherry explores the Architecture of the Pub Snug as a critical third space. Luke explores the development of these spaces, the social environment created, and the negotiation of these spaces as authentic embodiments of our culture and identity.

Read

Girls just want to have fun: How can we design public space for teenage girls?

Sinéad Hickey
Present Tense
Sinéad Hickey
Ciarán Brady

Teenagers may feel they need permission to play. Sometimes they just need space to loiter and talk ,but they are often misunderstood. As Jane Jacobs stated in The Death and Life of Great of Great American Cities “adolescents are always being criticised for this kind of loitering, but they can hardly grow up without it” [1].  Teenagers in county Kildare have said “adults made space for the younger kids but every time teenagers are in a space, they get kicked out or demonised” [2]. Adults have a duty to assist children and teenagers in creating the spaces they desire.

‍

Public and green spaces in Ireland often consist of pitches, MUGAs (multi-use games areas), and skateparks. These large and open spaces often end up being taken over by boys and men who play ball games which results  girls feeling left on the periphery. These areas are also usually surrounded by high fences with only one or two narrow exits. UK-based research carried out by Make Space for Girls discovered that 90% of the facilities provided for teenagers consisted of MUGAs, skateparks, and BMX tracks, and that 90% of the users are male. Within the same research, girls were three times more likely to use other facilities (e.g. shelters, swings, tennis courts) but 75% of these ‘other facilities’, which are designed by the councils, are shelters placed facing MUGAs and pitches [3]. This is not to say that these spaces are not valuable to certain demographics. It points to the fact that these spaces are not experienced equally and that girls are often designed out of public spaces intended for their age group. This results in them feeling excluded and uncomfortable. How can we design public space for teenage girls when we don’t listen to what they want?

‍

Locked gates at Liberty Park, Foley Street, Dublin 1. Image Credit: Sinéad Hickey

‍

After decades of cities being designed mainly for men as they went to and from work via car, Vienna was one of the first cities to adopt gender mainstreaming - the practice of accounting for all genders equally in design - as an urban design principle. Since the 1980s, Stadt Wien (City of Vienna) has implemented multiple strategies to diversify their city infrastructure. The widening of over one kilometre of footpaths makes space feel more accessible and less threatening, street lighting improvements provide a stronger sense of security, traffic lights have been altered to favour pedestrians, and the provision of more benches has provided to be the difference between someone participating in public versus staying home [4].

‍

Einsiedlerpark in the Margareten district was redesigned in 1999 based on local feedback from and conversations with girls in the area - they felt that there was nothing there for them. The number of girls using these spaces was decreasing from the age of nine. Hammocks and platforms were placed near the footpaths, described as ‘quick attractions’. Volleyball and badminton courts were added to neutralise the boys’ dominance over the caged basketball courts. A platform was added between the basketball courts simply to divide the large space into ‘sub-zones’ whilst also providing more seating. Lighting and footpaths were improved to encourage girls to linger. These might seem like small additions and amendments, but they can make a huge impact on the lifestyles of teenage girls. Since its completion, it has been enjoyed by many other demographics as well, specifically elderly people and young families [5].

‍

Quick attractions such as hammocks and platforms in Einsiedlerpark,Vienna. Image Credit: Zdenka Lammelova, WPS Prague

‍

Make Space for Girls is a UK-based charity that campaigns for girls to be considered in the design process of parks and public spaces. They provide workshops and interviews with girls, research precedents, and create design suggestions. They then present this research to councils, developers, and design professionals. They give a voice to teenage girls. From their observations, suitable park infrastructure includes swings, stages, exercise bars, benches with shelter and seating facing each other. Other public space features such as lighting, access, and footpaths are also critical in fostering girls in public areas [6].

‍

“What does better look like?”. Image Credit: Make Space for Girls

‍

In a 2019 survey by Teenspace of 500 teenagers in the South Dublin County Council area, more than 90 per cent of teenagers requested spaces for hanging out and for play and recreation while only 5 per cent asked for more sports facilities. Kildare County Council announced a pilot project in 2024, to design a park in Celbridge while involving teenagers in the process [6]. Both of these initiatives were aimed at teenagers of all genders. In Ireland, only 11% of teenage girls reach the recommended amount of daily physical activity [7]. A Level Playing Field, a not-for-profit, carried out a series of workshops with girls from Dublin between the ages of 12 and 16. Founded by Sarah Flynn in 2022, these workshops identified what made the girls feel unsafe and uncomfortable in public spaces. The girls then sketched their idea of improved public space at Charleville Mall, Dublin 1. These proposals included ‘increased lighting, seating for hanging out and chatting on, and playful interventions such as trampolines embedded in the paving’ [8]. These initiatives are catalysts for meaningful interventions by including girls in the process.

‍

Still, there is not enough being done to facilitate and foster girls in public space in Ireland. Dublin City Council states in their Dublin City Development Plan 2022 - 2028 that the Council will ‘during the lifetime of this Plan complete a study of Women and Girl’s Safety in the public realm in order to identify the factors that make women and girls feel safe and unsafe in public spaces’ [9]. This public research has not been carried out. The current lack of public toilets in Dublin is also a hindrance to girls - and many others. There is now only one public toilet in Dublin at St. Stephen’s Green which is currently planned to close [10]. Girls and women need reasonable access to public toilets for many reasons, specifically for menstruation, breastfeeding, and to care for children.

‍

The only way to create pleasant public spaces for teenage girls is to talk to them and listen to them. The lived experiences of girls deserve to be acknowledged and considered when it comes to the design of public space. Teenage girls believe they are left out due to feeling unsafe, but there are multiple ways to encourage girls to take up space. There is no one prescriptive solution to this matter which is why local research and engagement is vital to suit different contexts and provide meaningfully for women.

‍

Collage image from author’s MArch thesis. Image Credit: Sinéad Hickey
19/10/2026
Present Tense

In this article, Sinéad Hickey discusses gender mainstreaming in urban spaces through the lense of teenager and women in sport. Sinéad explores the nature of spaces provided for teenagers, the disparity in provision for genders, and the issues affecting teenage girls use of these public spaces in particular.

Read

Carrying Forward!

Ananya Jain
Present Tense
Ananya Jain
Ciarán Brady

Every time I move, something has to be rebuilt.

‍

Moving to a new place means setting up a new routine, building a new support network, and re-learning how things work - while leaving behind a version of yourself that you, and those around you, are familiar with. Migration can be described through the act of arrival, but for me, it is equally shaped by the sense of departure, having to establish myself again and figure out what I bring to the table.

‍

I moved to Birmingham as a 17 year old international student from Delhi. While I was studying architecture, I was also learning to navigate a new cultural and academic environment. I was surrounded by new references and different ways of communicating ideas, along with the pressure of developing a design language. For example, from the outside, crit culture is about pinning your work up on the wall. However, it requires confidence and the ability to defend your ideas, to question your own thinking, and sometimes to fail publicly, and, despite that, to have the courage to show up next week.

‍

Sarah Young, in her research on imposter syndrome, describes how critiques, comparisons, unwritten rules of architectural education, and demanding work hours can intensify feelings of self-doubt. In her survey, over 50% of first-year design studio participants reported moderate to intense feelings of being an imposter [1]. As I was still learning and finding my feet in a new country, the question of competency became more heightened, and I started to question if I truly belonged here.

‍

As I moved to Belfast for work, the questions did not disappear. Representation tells us who is present in a design studio or an office. However, belonging is revealed through actions upon entering. As I entered practice, I began considering whether there was trust, whether I was asked about my thoughts, whether I was encouraged to take part in a conversation or given an opportunity to resolve the unfamiliar, or whether I was taking responsibility before I felt ready.

‍

These moments matter as confidence is built through opportunities. Factors such as gender, race, disability, sexuality, and caring responsibilities can often influence whether people are given a chance to work directly with clients, take on complex projects, develop technical skills, or progress into visible leadership roles [2]. For me, being welcomed into the profession and being trusted within it were two very different realities.

‍

Mentorship has played an important role in helping me close the gap. Over the last year, I participated in mentoring schemes across the UK and was matched with three incredible female mentors who had also migrated to the country. Conversations with them helped me navigate progression, build confidence, and manage professional expectations. Most importantly, they challenged my imposter syndrome and helped me recognise that a lack of certainty should not be seen as a lack of potential.

‍

Yet, confidence alone can’t address the wider barriers to entering industry. The route to qualification in the profession remains long and financially demanding, especially for international graduates. At elite universities, international tuition fees can exceed £30,000 a year, yet entry-level roles offer little remuneration by comparison [3]. Recruitment can also reinforce barriers to the profession. The industry still operates through familiar networks, recommendations, and established universities. For people who are trained abroad, have migrated, or have followed an unconventional career path, it becomes even harder to get a foot in the door. For international graduates, there is an added sense of uncertainty alongside professional progression. There is a constant race against time due to visas, work sponsorship, and changing immigration policies.

‍

Similarly, architectural registration remains tied to national systems such as the Council of Architecture in India, the Architects Registration Board in the UK, and the Royal Institute of Architects of Ireland in Ireland. Working across countries and navigating new registration processes each time requires translating experience and qualifications to fit a new system.

‍

Having to prove your professional identity and build support networks all over again can seem daunting at first. However, with every move, I learned new ways to understand, communicate, and be resilient. My confidence now comes from knowing I have rebuilt before.

‍

I visited the London Festival of Architecture this year, and the central theme of ‘Belonging’ was explored through connection and participation [4]. It made me reflect that while architecture creates spaces for connection, the profession must also nurture the people entering, support those trying to stay, and create meaningful opportunities for progression. This is why I co-led ‘Portfolio Review and Mentoring Night’ last month with my colleague, Lois Chan, bringing together students and practitioners for portfolio feedback, career conversations, and professional connections. I have immensely benefited from the people around me who helped me to navigate the industry, and I hope to make the routes visible to others.

‍

Portfolio Review and Mentoring Evening. Image Credit: Lois Chan

‍

I am writing this in a time of great uncertainty about my next move. Yet I know with every move, I carry forward the confidence, the generosity of my mentors, diverse perspectives, and unique experiences. My experience is only one of many among the professions increasingly shaped by movement. The question then is, how does the industry recognise, value, and advocate for the talent it attracts from across the globe?

‍

The Veggery Greenhouse at Barbican Estate, built as part of the London Festival of Architecture 2026 in response to the theme of Belonging. Image Credit: Gemma Sandell
21/9/2026
Present Tense

In this article, Ananya Jain reflects on how different educational and professional environments shaped her sense of belonging through her journey from Delhi to Belfast, and the role mentorship, migration, identity, and belonging has played in her navigation of both architectural education and practice.

Read

Updates

Website by Good as Gold.